Why Wegovy Underdelivered
The math explains the disappointment — and points straight at the fix.
The Deficit Never Existed
Your estimated maintenance is ~2,100–2,200 cal/day (BMR ~1,660 + daily walks + lifting). Losing 4 lb in 5 months means the real average deficit was only ~90 cal/day — actual intake was ~2,000–2,100, not 1,800.
Appetite Went Sideways
The pills cut hunger but steered it toward rich, sugary, calorie-dense food — erasing the deficit — while dampening thirst, libido, and motivation. Net effect: side effects without results.
Protein at Half-Dose
65g/day is roughly half what a 183-lb man needs while losing weight. Low protein means poor satiety, muscle loss, and the evening cravings you've been fighting. This is the single biggest fix in the plan.
Daily Targets
Macros shift toward protein; calories drop to a real deficit. Old averages shown for contrast.
Macros: Wegovy months vs. this plan
Grams per day — protein doubles, carbs and fat trim slightly
Phase 1 — The Taper (weeks 1–4, while the 12 pills last)
Every-other-day, then every-3rd-day is directionally fine. The habits must be running before the drug fades.
Taper Schedule
Weeks 1–4- 9mg every other day until ~6 pills remain, then every 3rd day until gone.
- Semaglutide's half-life is ~1 week, so blood levels fade gradually either way.
- Side effects you disliked (low thirst, libido, motivation) should lift as it clears.
The Danger Window
Weeks 2–6 afterExpect appetite rebound 2–6 weeks after the last pill. This is where most people regain. Daily logging and 130g+ protein must already be automatic habits before it hits — which is why logging starts today, not after the taper.
The Eating Structure
Four anchors per day. Protein front-loaded, dinner solved without cooking two menus, evenings defended by protocol instead of willpower.
Breakfast — Protein Anchor
~350 cal30g+ protein before noon kills afternoon grazing. Rotate: 3 eggs any style · Greek yogurt bowl (1 cup plain + berries + splash of granola) · protein shake + banana.
Lunch — Biggest Protein Hit
~450 cal40g protein. Leftover dinner protein · tuna or chicken over bagged salad · on busy days, a high-protein/bariatric soup or shake — that's their job in this plan.
Dinner — The Two-Menu Fix
~550 calCook one shared protein for the whole family (sheet-pan chicken thighs, taco meat, salmon, pork tenderloin, rotisserie chicken). Family gets their sides; you plate protein + double vegetables + one fist of starch max. You never cook a separate meal — you just plate differently.
Evening Protocol
Your leak- “Dessert” is pre-planned and protein-based: Greek yogurt + frozen berries + honey drizzle (~150 cal). Log it at dinner time.
- Kitchen closes 8:30pm — brush teeth right after dessert (weirdly effective).
- Stress/boredom urge → 10-minute walk or sparkling water first, then decide. The urge usually dies.
- Trigger foods live in one cabinet you don't open — or don't get stocked.
The $250/Month
Extra spend on top of normal groceries. Skip meal delivery for now — at $10–13/meal it burns the whole budget on ~20 dinners you can already cook. Revisit only if dinners fail for a month.
Where the money goes
~$234 of the $250 cap
Why This Beats Wegovy's ROI
Wegovy pills ran $300/month and delivered 0.8 lb/month. This plan costs ~$225/month and targets 3–4 lb/month — because it fixes the actual problem (no real deficit, half-dose protein) instead of renting appetite suppression.
Cost per pound lost drops from roughly $375/lb ($1,500 over 5 months for 4 lb) to under $70/lb.
One-time gear (from the separate ~$300 device budget): Withings Body Smart scale ~$100 + $10 tape measure. Skip $300 scales — consumer body-fat sensors are trend tools at any price; you're buying auto-sync to Apple Health, not accuracy.
Projected Progress
0.75–1 lb per week from a 450-cal daily deficit. The shaded band is the realistic range; the flat gray line is the Wegovy trajectory you just left.
Exercise
Keep what works, upgrade what's token.
Keep: Daily 40-Min Walk
WorkingWorth ~250–300 cal/day and doubles as your anti-grazing tool (the 10-minute rule). Don't change it.
Upgrade: Lifting 3×/Week
Fitness+Use Apple Fitness+ strength programs — already paid for in your Apple One, and the Watch auto-logs every session to Health. Adherence trick: pick one trainer/program and pre-schedule the 3 days in Momentum instead of deciding daily.
Coming off a GLP-1 at low protein, you've likely lost muscle; rebuilding it raises maintenance calories and makes the loss come from fat.
Tech Stack — Apple Health Is the Hub
Everything writes to Apple Health automatically; Momentum reads it and becomes the scorecard dashboard. Nothing gets manually transcribed. One-time setup: enable iCloud → Health sync on iPhone and iPad.
docs/plans/2026-08-10-health-section-design.md in the Momentum repo. Three phases; Phase A (HealthKit dashboard) ships alone.Weekly Scorecard (check every Sunday)
- Logged food 6+ days?
- Protein averaged 120g+ per day?
- Weekly average weight + waist measurement vs. last week? (Weigh daily, judge only the weekly average.)
- Lifted 3× (Fitness+)?
- Evening protocol held 5+ nights?
The Momentum Health section will auto-compute 1–4 from Apple Health once built.